Approaches to Writing - Phase 3: Issue

What is an issue? An issue is a controversy related to your Question. It identifies at least two differing beliefs that people have on a particular matter. For example, if you write, "Some people believe THIS . . . , but other people believe THAT . . . ," you have identified an issue.

Consider the Question "Should amateur mountain climbers be prevented from climbing Mt. Everest?" Related to that Question are all of the following issues (among hundreds of others):

Photo of Mt. Everest
  • Some say amateur mountain climbers should be allowed to climb Mt. Everest, while others say such inexperienced climbers should be stopped.

  • Some people believe it is wrong for expedition companies to guide inexperienced climbers to the top of Mt. Everest, but others believe these companies are only satisfying the demands of inexperienced climbers.

  • Some people believe an age-limit should be set for children wanting to climb Mt. Everest (such as fifteen-year-old Arbin Timilsina), while others believe that a climber's physical health is all that matters.

Each of the issues above shows conflict. Even the "experts" will disagree about whether amatuer mountain climbing companies should be in business . . . or whether inexperienced climbers should be permitted on Mt. Everest . . . or whether children should be encouraged to climb the world's tallest mountain. They may not even agree on what an "amateur mountain climber" is.

That's good news for writers of research papers! Disagreement means that you will find a rich body of sources by authors of differing opinions. Later you will formulate a position on your own issue. For now, though, making a list of poential issues will allow you to become familiar with the controversies related to your topic--one of which you will choose to help you further narrow your topic and focus your research.

Examples of issues
(Notice that each issue is phrased as a complete sentence. Also, notice how all the issues show differing or conflicting viewpoints, even though they may not be worded in the same manner.)
Some say El Niño caused much unnecessary spending on damage control devices, while others say the money was well spent.
Even though most Americans reject Iraqi aggression, many also desire access to Iraqi oil.
Although some American consumers discourage the use of rabbits in cosmetic testing, others demand more cosmetic testing than ever before.
Many believe Radial Keratonomy (RK) offers hope for many nearsighted people, but others believe that the technique has not been around long enough to be guaranteed safe.
Some Nez Perce people welcome the return of the traditional "drummer" religion to their reservation, while others say it challenges the Nez Perce Christian leadership.
Some believe the movie Titanic gave an accurate portrayal of the Titanic disaster, while others claim it distorted the facts.
Some say that anti-loitering laws prevent violence by gang members, while others say such laws are mistakenly applied to non-gang minority youth.

Any questions or comments for Kenn?

Where do I go next?
Go to "Assignment 3A" to develop a list of potential issues.

Web Architect: Michael L. Geiger
Content by Kenn Pierson
Created 1.21.98 - Last Updated: 6.1.00
©2000 M.L.Geiger
URL: http://www.kjpierson.com/TEACHING/ENG101